Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Reflections on an Historic Election: Argentina Enters a New Crisis


Historic vote: The Argentinian Workers Party newspaper celebrates 1.2 million votes for the Workers and Left Front in the October mid-term elections. Credit: http://prensa.po.org.ar
By Bob Lyons
New Socialist Webzine
November 3, 2013


The historic Argentinean mid-term elections of 27 October resulted in a breakthrough for the revolutionary left, and has exposed more clearly the outline of the tendencies emerging at the time of the primary votes held in July. The political, economic and social fissures revealed by the vote can be grouped around three themes:
1.    the end of the Kirchnerist experiment and the resulting strategic incoherance of the Argentinean bourgeoisie as a whole;
2.    the radical deepening of the economic and fiscal crises of the Argentinean state expressed as a loss of political legitimacy, and a series of policy cul-de-sacs;
3.    the growing presence of a workers and social vanguard determined to resist the consequences of the global crisis as expressed locally.
In what follows we will attempt to situate the election, and especially the results for the revolutionary left, within the context of the above themes.
The Defeat of Kirchnerism
That Kirchnerism, the political strategy of first Nestor and then Cristina is over is evidenced by the vote total obtained by the Front of Victory, the electoral apparatus of a renovated Peronism. In 2011 at the time of the presidential elections, Cristina Kirchner won with 54% of the national vote. Now a brief two years later she struggled to reach 33%. At a regional level, where the byzantine web of alliances between mayors, governors and national figures are expressed, Kirchner was defeated in the all-important province of Buenos Aires by the Renovation Front of Sergio Massas, the exponent of the neo-liberalism of the industrial and agrarian establishment, by a margin of more than 10%.
The defeat of Kirchnerism is not however a victory for a coherent alternative policy. Posing as a center left alternative, Kirchnerism arose as a response to the years of social tension, economic chaos and massive political resistance to neo-liberalism following the fall of the military dictatorship. It was an attempt to appear to rise above the class struggles taking place and to offer a solution to the nation's problems, a mediation between the classes and fractions of the ruling class which would place the salvation of Argentinean capitalism ahead of sectoral interests.The electoral defeat which it has just suffered is a sign that not only has its political strategy failed, but the policy initiatives which it undertook to solve the economic crisis are a failure as well.
A Bankrupt Policy in a Bankrupt State
The context in which the election took place is prefigured by two reinforcing processes: the global crisis of capitalism in its neo-liberal variant, and the specific features of the fiscal crisis of the state. While crisis is a much over used term generally, in the case of Argentina it really does apply.
Argentina is a developed industrial economy relying on internal consumption and exports of its agricultural and manufactured goods, the latter primarily within Latin America. More than 90% of the population lives in urban areas including Mendoza, Cordoba, Tucuman, Salta, and of course Buenos Aires and the surrounding municipalities. It has a highly educated working class relatively speaking and a long history of workers and popular struggles, with students playing an important political role as relays for socialist ideas and analysis.
Since 2002, when the depression of 1998 to 2004 caused the collapse of the Argentinean economy and an outright default by the short-lived Saa administration, the effects of the neo-liberal prescriptions applied by the International Monetary Fund have only exacerbated the structural problems of Argentinean capitalism. Although Argentina paid off its full IMF debt in 2006, in no small part as a result of the peso devaluation by Duhalde in 2002 and the resulting influx of foreign investment and export revenues, the world wide crisis of 2008 set off internal processes which now emerge as another crisis with debt as the core determinant.
Since 1975 Argentina has paid over $600 billion in debt and interest payments to foreign lenders. Kristina Kirchner, when faced with mounting opposition to paying a portion of the debt which many economists see as dubious if not illegitimate, has personally supervised the paying of $173 billion during her administration. Despite this, the net Argentinean debt has risen by over $100 billion to now stand in excess of $200 billion in US dollars.
In order to service this debt, the Kirchners engaged in a policy of robbing Peter to pay Paul, with Peter being the Argentinean people. The process of partial nationalisations of the private pension pools was a method to strip them of their hard cash assets and replace them with Argentine government bonds of obvious dubious quality. Similarily, the partial nationalisation of the petroleum assets was to ensure enough foreign reserve flows to feed the debt monster.
So while the sacred obligation of debt repayment was honored by Kirchner's policies, the burden of this was borne by the Argentinean working class. The fact that Kirchner's policies were class based and class biased was made clear to Argentineans by the treatment of the holding of US dollars. One of the currency controls introduced by Kirchner was to forbid the holding of US dollars, requiring that any dollars entering the country were to be exchanged for pesos. According to Cristina Kirchner, this policy was to apply to all sectors as a method of squelching the parallel market, and halting the outflows of foreign denominated currencies.
The hypocrisy of this measure was exposed when it was revealed that the administration had signed a deal with Chevron allowing them to repatriate their profits in dollars in exchange for investments in the partially nationalised YPF oil firm. This deal became a symbol of the corruption underlying the policy initiatives of the Kirchner regime, and has resulted in a tangible loss of legitimacy.
Despite the best efforts of the regime to try an engage in a policy whose heart is debt service (Kirchner herself famously described herself as a "serial payer"), the end of the road has come. In a landmark case in a New York courtroom this past month, the "rights" of a group of bondholders who refused to accept the restructuring of their Argentine bonds in 2003 were upheld and the court ordered full and immediate repayment. The Argentinean government has refused to recognize the authority of the court but is caught in a legal trap. If they don't pay this group of bondholders, who represent 24% of the total debt in 2005 dollars, then Argentina is in technical default. If they do repay they will then have to come up with a sum which they don't have and can't afford to borrow, given the declining revenue base and the level of absolute debt. The policy options have become very narrow indeed.
The Workers and Left Front
Within this ongoing economic and social crisis whose rhythms have been uneven and variable, the struggle of the Argentinean working class and popular sectors to maintain their standard of living and their labour and social rights has produced a militant and class conscious political and social vanguard layer which is increasing in size and self confidence. This was expressed by the size of the vote for the Workers and Left Front (WLF - Frente Izquierda y de los Trabajadores), an electoral coalition involving three Trotskyist political organisations.
The WLF received almost one million, two hundred and fifty thousand votes from all areas of the country, with a few scattered exceptions. This vote resulted in the election to the national parliament of three MP's, and in addition resulted in the election of eight more members of provincial legislatures plus dozens of members to municipal councils.
The WLF was formed to contest the national elections of 2011. Its three components are the Partido Obrero (Workers' Party), the Partido Trabajadores Socialistas (The Socialist Workers Party), and the Izquierda Socialista (Socialist Left). All three come from the tradition of Latin American revolutionary Marxism inspired by the politics of legendary Argentinian Trotskyist leader Nahuel Moreno. Indeed all three originated in the MAS, the Movement to Socialism founded by Moreno which at one time grouped 12,000 adherents.
The consequences of this historic vote were summed up by the national newspaper El Clarin in the headline "The combative left now has its October." Despite the ironic nod to the month of the Russian revolution, the fact that the WLF was able to emerge as a significant force to the left of "left Peronism" is a sign that the traditional political relays of the Argentinean workers movement are breaking apart.
The vote for the WLF was impressive. Running on an explicitly revolutionary platform, the candidates of the WLF received 19% of the total vote in Mendoza, 16% in Salta, and almost a half million votes in the national capital region. For the first time ever the revolutionary left was able to credibly present itself as a radical alternative to Peronism.
The WLF vote signals a rising combativity of the Argentinean working class whose tendency was established at the time of the 2011 elections where the WLF received around 600,000 votes. In the space of two years the revolutionary left has doubled the size of its vote. In fact, in the primary elections of July, the WLF received around 900,000 votes. The increase in support in 3 months has risen by 30%. But the WLF was not the only revolutionary organisation running. When all the organisations which presented themselves as radical left alternatives are added together, the vote total rises to over a million and a half votes.
The immediate consequences of the successes of the WLF have been within the fractured Argentinean left itself. The great bulk of the revolutionary left in Argentina identifies with revolutionary Marxism of the Trotskyist tradition. There were at last count 21 different organisations identifying themselves as Trotskyist. The day following the election results Jorge Altimira, spokesperson of the PO, and Christian Castillo, leader identified with the PTS, both issued a call for the rest of the left to unite around the WLF project, and to engage in talks aimed at unifying the revolutionary Marxist left.
This has brought pressure to bear on one of the major organisations of the revolutionary left, the Socialist Workers Movement (MST), whose strategy of attempting to build a new broad left is seen in contradistinction to that of the WLF's more orthodox Trotskyist politics. This strategy now appears to lie in tatters as some of its former allies, such as filmmaker Pino Solano and his Proyecto Sur (Southern Project) ditched the MST without warning just weeks prior to the July primary elections.
This being said, the WLF cannot afford to ignore the MST. Unlike the three components of the WLF, the MST has permanent observer status at the Fourth International, and its politics could be described as closer to that of the French New Anticapitalist Party. It has relations with the Venezuelan revolutionary Marxist current Marea Socialista (Socialist Tide) and together both organizations held a revolutionary youth camp and political school in March of this year, attended by over 2,000 young people from five different countries of South America.
Immediately following the election results, the leading spokesperson for the MST, city of Buenos Aires deputy Alejandro Bodart, issued a plea to the leadership of the WLF to begin to find ways to unite the entire left around the project on a democratic basis.
If the WLF is able to show the leadership skills and political maturity to find a method to incorporate the MST, as well as the other significant tendencies within the Argentinean revolutionary left in its project, the Front would be strengthened politically as well as organisationally. The MST, for example has many worker leaders in its ranks and it is an integral part of the leadership of the Argentine Workers Central, the second largest workers central in the country.
Outside of Argentina, the call for Marxist unity and the results which would possibly be achieved because of it will have an effect on the revolutionary left from Mexico to Chile and from Brazil to France. Each one of the component organisations of the WLF has sister organisations in a host of countries in Latin America, in some countries all three organisations compete with each other to build "their" revolutionary international. If the experience of Argentina is translated and mediated in a framework and spirit of building a democratic process of unity capacity, the impact will have enormous and favourable consequences for each of the national lefts and workers' movements.
This will not be easy, given the history of organisational disunity, personal feuds, sectarian practice and a lack of a strategic consensus in the revolutionary left. It will take a great deal of political skill, tact, respect and trust building on the part of the leaders of not only the WLF to make this goal a reality.
In the meantime, the combative workers and popular sectors now have a small but significant national voice across Argentina. It is a voice and political instrument which will be soon be put to the test as the near term unfolds and the Argentinean ruling class attempts to find even more ways to make the workers pay for their crisis.

The article was written by Robert Lyons, a long time (very long time) Latin American solidarity activist living in Central America. He is a former New Democratic Party member of the Saskatchewan Legislative Assembly and trade union organiser.

7 comments:

  1. Everest Base Camp Trekking often touted as one of the most beautiful of trekking trips in the whole world and rightly it is. Located at the lap of world's highest peak, Everest Base Camp (EBC) is rewarded as the best trip Nepal has to offer. Since 1920, Mt Everest has captivated intrepid men and women. There were some exploits of legends like Sir Edmund Hillary, George Mallory and Tenzing Norgay Sherpa to put the mighty mountains on the map. Thousands of adventurers followed them making huge sacrifices. EBC Trek is designed to fulfill the dream of many people to experience the historic route to the base of world's highest peak. Since the beginning, Everest Base Camp Route has gained massive popularity and a lot of appreciation. The highlights of Everest Base Camp Trekking are the stunning views of Mount Everest, legendary Sherpa culture, wonderful Namche Bazaar, Tengboche Monastery, the best viewpoint of Kalapatthar, and beautiful Chhukung valley among many others. We gradually ascend through the wonderful Sherpa villages enjoying the magnificent Himalayan scenery, wildlife and visit a number of Buddhist Monasteries. EBC Trek culminates with a fine opportunity to trek to both EBC and nearby peak of Kalapatthar (5545m) for spectacular views of the Everest. Savoring the high mountain views with the unique and life defining journey, EBC trip can be combined with Gokyo Chola Pass Trek, or Everest Three Passes packages as well, making the journey bit more challenging and rewarding too. Encounters Nepal has carefully devised an itinerary with a number of rest days that offers an exceptional way to acclimatize safely. Having had hit the Himalayan Trails since so long, we have learned never to rush a trek to altitude in the Himalaya. Taking an extra few days makes all the difference to really being able to enjoy the trek and trekking in Nepal.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Namaste from a Beautiful Himalaya Nepal
    Nepal Base Camp Treks is government register agency (licensed trekking guide team) in the Nepalese Himalayas Ranges… After working 18 years (since 1997) on the tough trails for several years as a mountain staff crew, and working so hard to develop our fluency in English languages, We became a guide in the year 2000 to 2002. We have spent the past 18 years as a professional Himalaya trekking guide, working for several Trek & Expedition companies in Kathmandu; we have now decided to work as an independent guide and self leading to provide all our national and international clients, who like to enjoy their Himalaya trekking holidays tour with us (www.nepalbasecamptreks.com)
    In the last 18 years working experiences, our team have become very well-known with many Trekking Destinations throughout the country, this includes: The Everest Base Camp Treks, Annapurna Regions and Langtang Valley Regions, As well as Upper Mustang Treks, Manaslu Circuit Treks, Annapurna Circuit Trek,Ganesh Himal Trek, Helambu and all non tourist regions. Our teams at Nepal Base Camp Treks have studied well the lay of the land & our knowledgeable about local flora and fauna, cultural history and environmental issues in the areas where we trek are absolutely sound today. Our guests truly appreciate our services. We are able to guide Trekkers hoping to climb high passes Chola, Renjo La, thorong La,Larke La, Kongma La and peaks, & can take them to show exclusive spots for any adventures across the Himalayas. Nepal Base Camp Treks experience also covers the well known peaks of Mera Peak climbing , Island Peak Climbing,Lobuje Peak Climbing, Phakchhermo Peak, Pisang Peak, Tent Peak Kalapathar Peak & Gokyo Peak, and we have led expeditions across many high passes in Nepal, covers some famous mountains: Manaslu Circuit Larke Pass, Ampu-lapcha Pass, Makalu sherpani col Pass, east col Pass, west col Pass, Chola Pass, Renjula Pass, Rolwaling Tashilapcha Pass, Ganjala Pass, Ganesh himal Pangsang Pass, Thorong Pass and Tilicho Pass…ON THE WAY, AFTER ALL THE TRIALS & HARDSHIPS…THE BLOOD, SWEAT & TEARS…we are now an accomplished guide team who helps our guests unleash the best experiences ever in High Himalaya and Wild Adventures under their feet
    Treks come in many forms on Nepal's rugged Himalayas: ranging from the relaxed easy trekking where you can experience Nepalese Culture and Village life,Chitwan,Dhulekhel,Kathmandu Valley, Pokhara Ghale Gaun, to tea-house trekking in popular regions, Annapurna, Everest, Lantang, to unique treks into areas of Nepal that are off the beaten path and seldom visited by foreigners or remote non-touristic area Tawal Village, Chitwan Chepang Hill. All treks offer superb scenery and viewpoints into Nepal's exotic ancient culture. With our kind of experience, we can tailor your treks to meet your conveniences in any way that's comfortable to you.
    Nepal Base Camp Treks (Pvt. Ltd.)
    Post Box: 10114, Bhagwati Bahal Mark, Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal
    Telephone: + 977-1-4436088. Mobile: +977-9851111874
    Email: sappayesnepal@gmail.com
    info@nepalbasecamptreks.com
    URL:- www.nepalbasecamptreks.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nepal Everest Base camp Treks' s heartily welcome to you. Nepal Everest Base Camp Treks Pvt. Ltd. was established as a successful result of decade’s long involvement and long experienced in Nepalese tourism industry. Having had experience of operating and leading wonderful adventure Trips in some of the most captivating vistas of Nepal Himalayas successfully. we have been providing service with interesting trekking packages. i.e. Everest Base camp trekking, Everest three pass trekking, Everest trekking, Annapurna base camp trekking, Annapurna circuit trekking, Annapurna ghorepani poon hill trekking, Ghorepani poon hill trekking, ghorepani ghandrunk trekking, khayera ridge trekking, Annapurna sanctuary trekking, Poon hill trekking, Annapurna Trekking, Manaslu trekking, Manaslu circuit trekking, Manaslu Tsum valley Trekking, Langtang valley Trekking,Langtang Tamang heritage Trekking,Langtang Gosainkunda pass Trekking,Helambu Trekking,Helambu cultural trekking,langtang Ganja la pass trekking,Upper mustang Trekking,Mustang Trekking,Jomsom muktinath trekking,Upper Dolpa Trekking, Ruby valley trekking,Ganesh himal trekking etc to several kind of recreation loving tourist destinations since 2005 however we are keen of promoting our company service therefore.
    Nepal Everest Base Camp Treks Pvt. Ltd.
    Saat Ghumti Thamel, Kathmandu, Nepal
    Mobile No:+977- 9841902116
    info@nepaleverestbasecamptreks.com
    anjan99nebct@gmail.com
    www.nepaleverestbasecamptreks.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Welcome to Base Camp Trekking Tour! Hundred percent pure lands of highest Himalaya's adventures
    Trekking in Nepal is one of the best adventure government registered company operating all adventure holidays trip to world most popular mountains Everest Base Camp Treks, Annapurna Base Camp Treks, Langtang Treks, Manaslu Treks, as well Upper mustang trek, Ganesh Himal Treks, Langtang Ganja La Pass Treks and all popular sightseeing tour of Ancients Kathmandu Valley and relaxing Chitwan Lumbini Tour on your desirable local budget for national and international travelers to Nepal.
    Nepal Base Camp Treks (P) Ltd.(www.basecamptrekkingtour.com) may be your next Trekking and Trekking Company in Nepal for any Trekking Agency in Nepal to highlander Himalayas Everest base camp, best mountain sceneries Annapurna Base Camp, recently promoting Manaslu Circuit Trek, several High passes Thorong La Annapurna Circuit,Gokyo Lake Chola Pass,Gokyo Lake Renjo La Pass, Chhukung Kongma La Pass, Rolwaling Tashilapchha Pass, Gosaikund Lake Pass, Kathmandu Valley Cultural trek and tour,Dhulekhel Namoduddha, Nagarkot trek, Bungmati Tour, Chiwan Chepang Hill Trek, Bandipur Tour,Pokhara Valley trekking tour,Ghorepani Poon Hill Trek, Annpurna Ghandruk Trek, Kanchanjanga north to south Pass,Langtang Ganja La Pass, depending small group travelers to joining group travelers on your desired budget to standard budget.
    Nepal Base Camp Treks offers you very popular non tourist destinations as remote regions of manaslu Tsum Valley Trek, Nar-Phu Valley Trek, Tamang Heritage Trail, Ghale Gaun Trek, Kanchanjanga Base Camp Trek, Rolwaling Camping Trek, Upper Mustang Cultural Trek, Lower Dolpo and Upper Dolpo Trek on very reasonable social trek in non touristic destination to better understand your holidays with our professional team
    Our team in Nepal Base Camp Treks is very profession of peak climbing experiences of most popular Island Peak, Lobuje Peak, Mera Peak, Phakchhermo Peak in Everest Region and Pisang Peak, Kanguru Peak, Chulu Peak in Annapurna Circuit Region and Tent Peak in Annapurna Base Camp.
    We guaranteed you best services and trouble less during your lifetime holidays journey with our professional mountain local team and wish you have a nice journey and see you soon in Nepal here to dream your adventure awaits you, as I remain
    Yours sincerely
    Sappa Lama (Sagar) and team
    info@basecamptrekkingtour.com
    www.basecamptrekkingtour.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. holiday activity in the country. The two classic trekking routes either to Everest base camp or the Annapurna circuit are not easy and the challenge you'll face on either route will have a lasting effect. The Manaslu route trek around the world's eighth largest mountain is more remote but no less beautiful passing through stunning bamboo forests, villages filled with prayer flags and culminating with spectacular views from Larkya La. Mustang is an easier cultural trek, suitable for those with good general fitness but not necessarily any previous trekking experience. The language, culture and tradition of the Mustang region are still mostly Tibetan making this one of the most culturally interesting treks. There are shorter treks up the Langtang Valley and Helambu which are still hard work but also deeply rewarding. They generally begin in Kathmandu, leading through large grazing areas covered in flowers, dotted with stone huts used for butter making, Sherpa, Tamang villages and the homes of yak herders, right up to the Tibetan border.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Welcome to Base Camp Trekking Tour! Hundred percent pure lands of highest Himalaya's adventures
    Trekking in Nepal is one of the best adventure government registered company operating all adventure holidays trip to world most popular mountains Everest Base Camp Treks, Annapurna Base Camp Treks, Langtang Treks, Manaslu Treks, as well Upper mustang trek, Ganesh Himal Treks, Langtang Ganja La Pass Treks and all popular sightseeing tour of Ancients Kathmandu Valley and relaxing Chitwan Lumbini Tour on your desirable local budget for national and international travelers to Nepal.
    Nepal Base Camp Treks (P) Ltd.(www.basecamptrekkingtour.com) may be your next Trekking and Trekking Company in Nepal for any Trekking Agency in Nepal to highlander Himalayas Everest base camp, best mountain sceneries Annapurna Base Camp, recently promoting Manaslu Circuit Trek, several High passes Thorong La Annapurna Circuit,Gokyo Lake Chola Pass,Gokyo Lake Renjo La Pass, Chhukung Kongma La Pass, Rolwaling Tashilapchha Pass, Gosaikund Lake Pass, Kathmandu Valley Cultural trek and tour,Dhulekhel Namoduddha, Nagarkot trek, Bungmati Tour, Chiwan Chepang Hill Trek, Bandipur Tour,Pokhara Valley trekking tour,Ghorepani Poon Hill Trek, Annpurna Ghandruk Trek, Kanchanjanga north to south Pass,Langtang Ganja La Pass, depending small group travelers to joining group travelers on your desired budget to standard budget.
    Nepal Base Camp Treks offers you very popular non tourist destinations as remote regions of manaslu Tsum Valley Trek, Nar-Phu Valley Trek, Tamang Heritage Trail, Ghale Gaun Trek, Kanchanjanga Base Camp Trek, Rolwaling Camping Trek, Upper Mustang Cultural Trek, Lower Dolpo and Upper Dolpo Trek on very reasonable social trek in non touristic destination to better understand your holidays with our professional team
    Our team in Nepal Base Camp Treks is very profession of peak climbing experiences of most popular Island Peak, Lobuje Peak, Mera Peak, Phakchhermo Peak in Everest Region and Pisang Peak, Kanguru Peak, Chulu Peak in Annapurna Circuit Region and Tent Peak in Annapurna Base Camp.
    We guaranteed you best services and trouble less during your lifetime holidays journey with our professional mountain local team and wish you have a nice journey and see you soon in Nepal here to dream your adventure awaits you, as I remain
    Yours sincerely
    Sappa Lama (Sagar) and team
    info@basecamptrekkingtour.com
    www.basecamptrekkingtour.com

    ReplyDelete